John N. Huffington, once a death row inmate, now stands as a plaintiff. After spending 32 years behind bars for murders he did not commit, Huffington has filed a federal civil lawsuit to hold those responsible accountable.
His claim targets former prosecutors, law enforcement, and Harford County officials who, according to court documents, knowingly allowed a flawed case to destroy his life. The arrest came in 1981.
The pardon came in 2023. Between those two milestones lies a four-decade battle marked by prosecutorial misconduct, hidden evidence, coerced testimony, and a flawed forensic process once endorsed by the FBI.
The scars are personal. The implications are systemic.
Huffington’s Arrest and Convictions
On May 25, 1981, Diane Becker was found stabbed to death in her RV in Abingdon, Maryland. Her boyfriend, Joseph Hudson, was found fatally shot a few miles away.
The murders sparked public outcry, and within days, authorities zeroed in on John Huffington, then only 18.
Double Convictions and Death Row
Prosecutors claimed that forensic hair analysis connected Huffington to the crime. That analysis, presented by FBI agent Michael Malone, later came under intense scrutiny. Huffington faced trial twice:
| Year | Outcome | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1981 | Convicted, death sentence | Vacated due to improper testimony |
| 1983 | Re-convicted, death sentence | The sentence was later commuted to life |
He would remain in prison for 32 years, including 10 on death row.
What the FBI and DOJ Never Told the Court?
Between 1997 and 1999, the FBI and the U.S. Department of Justice issued letters warning that the hair analysis used in Huffington’s conviction was flawed.
The letters cited FBI agent Malone’s false testimony. Prosecutor Joseph Cassilly, then the state’s attorney for Harford County, received those letters and kept them hidden.
Cassilly never notified the defense, the courts, or the public. That silence lasted more than a decade.
The Post’s Breakthrough in 2011
In 2011, a Washington Post investigation uncovered the buried DOJ letter. Huffington’s legal team, attorneys at Ropes & Gray, used it to launch a new appeal.
DNA testing in 2013 confirmed the truth: the hair did not match Huffington. The case collapsed. A new trial was ordered.
The Alford Plea: A Reluctant Step Toward Freedom
By 2017, Huffington faced an impossible decision. He could proceed to a third trial, risking another conviction, or accept an Alford plea. Under this plea, a defendant asserts innocence but concedes that sufficient evidence exists for a conviction.
He chose the latter. He was sentenced to time served. But he never accepted guilt.
“That was easily the hardest decision of my life,” Huffington later said.
Pardon and Compensation: A Formal Recognition of Innocence
@wmar2news It took 42 years for one Maryland man to finally get exonerated from a double murder he didnโt commit. โQuite honestly until you have had your freedom taken, you have no concept of what it is like to be free,” John Huffington said. Huffington was convicted of murdering a woman and her boyfriend on Memorial Day in 1981. He never committed the murders but spent 32 years in prison, 10 of those on death row. Now as a free man, John dedicates his time to pouring back into incarcerated people who are going through similar situations. He said its vital for the justice system to correct any mistakes so people wont be wrongfully convicted. โAs fast as we are to close the case and reassure the public that the perpetrator is not on the street anymore and you can rest easy at night again. When weโre made aware of an error it should be that same rush and that same expediency to fixing it,” says John. โSystems are run by people and its people that will make mistakes, not necessarily the system and if we can start reaching those people at the beginning of those careers and hoping to educate them on the mistakes that had happened and on best practices just so they can do a better job, I think we can end up with a system that as Americans we can be proud of,” says John. #innocent #news #update #inspiring #change #innocenceproject #innocence โฌ original sound – WMAR-2 News
In January 2023, Maryland Governor Larry Hogan granted Huffington a full pardon.
By July, the Maryland Board of Public Works awarded him $2.9 million in compensation, calculated using a statutory formula.
Compensation Calculated Under the Walter Lomax Act
| Factor | Amount |
|---|---|
| Years Wrongfully Imprisoned | 32 |
| Rate per Year | $91,431 |
| Total Award | $2,925,792 |
The New Lawsuit: Names, Allegations, and Legal Strategy
On July 15, 2025, Huffington filed a civil lawsuit in federal court in Baltimore. The case targets the following individuals and entities:
Named Defendants
- Joseph I. Cassilly – Former Harford County State’s Attorney (Deceased)
- Gerard Comen – Assistant State’s Attorney (Deceased)
- William Van Horn – Sheriff’s Detective (Deceased)
- Wesley J. Picha – Sheriff’s Detective (Deceased)
- David Saneman – Sheriff’s Detective (Alive)
- Harford County Government – Disputed employer responsibility
Cassilly’s widow issued a statement calling him “an honorable man,” but declined to respond directly to the lawsuit’s allegations.
Key Allegations in the Lawsuit
- Suppression of Exculpatory Evidence
- Malicious Prosecution
- False Arrest
- Coerced Testimony in Five Other Cases
- Denial of Constitutional Rights
The lawsuit argues that Cassilly acted as a policymaker for the county, making the local government liable. County officials reject that claim, saying the prosecutor’s office operates as a state entity.
Life After Prison
View this post on Instagram
Even before his 2017 release, Huffington had begun building a new life. He worked as a logistics manager for a demolition firm that offered job training to ex-offenders.
Later, he served as Director of Workforce Development at the Living Classrooms Foundation. He now leads operations at the Kinetic Capital Community Foundation.
Personal Cost of Injustice
- Denied permission to attend his mother’s funeral
- Lost the final years with his father, who suffered Alzheimer’s
- Missed decades of family milestones
“Neither of my parents ever got to see and understand that my name was cleared,” Huffington said.
A Story Still Unfolding
Mr. John Huffington was granted a full pardon of all charges on January 13, 2023. While acknowledging that money can never truly compensate for the time he lost, Comptroller Lierman voted to award $2.99 million to Mr. Huffington. A significant step towards justice and closure. pic.twitter.com/a1yupymRRa
โ Comptroller of Maryland Brooke Lierman (@MDComptroller) July 5, 2023
Judge Brendan A. Hurson will preside over the case. A trial date has not been set. For now, John Huffington continues to seek the accountability that eluded him for decades.
“It took many, many painful years, but the truth eventually came out. I want justice. Not only for me, but to make sure this never happens again.”
His idea of justice has changed. He is no longer fighting for himself alone. He is speaking for those who still have no voice.
Final Thoughts
Countless others have walked the same brutal path, each one carrying the weight of a system that failed to tell the truth when it mattered most.
Ronald Cotton was convicted through mistaken identity and spent a decade in prison before DNA evidence cleared his name.
Kerry Max Cook endured multiple trials and years on death row while prosecutors buried the very facts that could have saved him.
Daniel Villegas, only a teenager, signed a confession after hours of pressure and fear, then spent nearly two decades fighting to prove he had been forced into a lie.
Malcolm Scott served more than 20 years after being convicted on testimony that was later recanted, and he is still waiting for his name to be restored.
These were not isolated errors. Each case carried warnings that the system chose to ignore. John Huffington is not the first man to lose his freedom to misconduct and silence.
Without deep reform, he will not be the last.
